how fake science websites hijack our trust in experts to misinform and confuse
Fake science websites are dressing up their content as verified and authoritative. Credit: M_Agency/Shutterstock

The scientific method is rigorous. Claims and premises are supported with evidence. The peer review system is designed to ensure that research is scrutinized by experts before publication. And whenever researchers lack certainty, they’ll emphasize that “further research is necessary” to land on the truth.

Unfortunately, fake science websites are learning to appear equally rigorous in order to trick their audiences into believing fringe, debunked and bogus theories. These websites seek to take advantage of our trust in experts, and the methods we use to verify information, to lend authority to anti-science positions.

Some even hyperlink to fake science published in what appear to be peer-reviewed journals but are in fact open access publishers who will accept anything submitted, provided their fees are paid.

Research shows that the anti-science movement is escalating and globalizing. In a recent global survey, almost 50% of respondents said they see false or misleading information online every day. Over half of those who shared such information did so because they thought it was true at the time.

Fake science that masquerades as trustworthy and authoritative information is harder to spot. But by understanding the methods fake science websites are using, we can adjust our verification techniques to ensure we don’t fall for their deception.

Source material

Fake science websites use extensive hyperlinking to facilitate the appearance of trustworthiness. Hyperlinks act as visual markers of credibility, appearing to connect content to a source. The mere presence of a link can provide readers with a sense that a particular claim is verified and that the author has done their research.

You’ll know from your own browsing that checking every hyperlink to read and evaluate the information cited requires effort. For those who are not well-versed in scientific principles, methodology and analytical techniques, it is even more demanding. For convenience, we often trust the presence of a link or citation as proof that the information expressed is credible.

Repeated posts also add to the appearance of credibility. Research has found that virtually any claim uttered by a contrarian scientist, whether it challenges the consensus on anthropogenic climate change or calls into question individual scientists, immediately gets picked up and shared through the climate change blogosphere.

This content is copied from one site to another until dozens of websites feature the same information. The aim is not only to increase the content’s visibility, but also to ensure search engine results pages are populated with the same repeated content.

Readers who attempt to verify information through “lateral reading,” or opening a series of tabs to read a selection of different articles, may come across several pages of results that appear to corroborate what they read on a single fake science website. Globally, 24% of people use this verification technique. Fake science articles also hyperlink to this repeated content, increasing the likelihood that readers will see it as legitimate.

Many fake science websites never actually produce any original articles. They regurgitate anything that supports their position in order to make that position more visible, hoping that web users won’t have time to figure out that a single article has been copied dozens of times.


The strategies formerly used by the tobacco industry are now applied to climate science.

Manufacturing doubt

The manufacturing of doubt is another common strategy used across many anti-science positions. Research has shown that the tobacco industry engaged with this strategy to cast doubt on links between smoking and cancer. The same strategy is now used to downplay the climate crisis.

Due to the sheer weight of scientific evidence of anthropogenic global warming, fake science websites avoid outright climate denial and instead critique climate concerns as overblown and climate policies as extreme. The objective is not to invalidate the position but to foster doubt about the reality of climate change.

To this end, articles again create the illusion of scientific rigor by referring to a selected body of evidence which is often misinterpreted or not peer-reviewed. Meanwhile, research that confirms the severity of the climate crisis is labeled “climate alarmism” and dismissed as “doom mongering.”

Spotting fake science

Fake science websites aggressively share their articles, encouraging web users to do the same, so it’s likely that they will appear in your social media or search engine feed. They’re easy to spot if you know what to look out for.

First, check the hyperlinks used in the article. Fake science websites will direct you to websites that aren’t reputable, to websites that aren’t relevant, or to articles identical to the one you’re reading.

You can also copy and paste part of a suspect article into a search engine to check how often it has been reposted. Genuine science and research is reposted on reputable websites, but fake science will be copied among a series of websites you’ve never heard of.

If you’re still in doubt about an article’s legitimacy, visit a website that is dedicated to unpacking misinformation and bias, such as mediabiasfactcheck.com, where you can check if a website is known to feature fake science.

Ultimately, fake science websites can only assume the appearance of credibility. They’re hoping that web users won’t have the time or the skills to discover that what they’re reading lacks scientific proof. With that in mind, digging a little deeper can help us expose sham science from legitimate, expert sources. Provided by The Conversation

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Citation: How fake science websites hijack our trust in experts to misinform and confuse (2022, September 13) retrieved 13 September 2022 from https://phys.org/news/2022-09-fake-science-websites-hijack-experts.html This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Keyword: How fake science websites hijack our trust in experts to misinform and confuse

TECH'S NEWS RELATED

Tesla robot walks, waves, but doesn't show off complex tasks

Tesla Motors, Inc. CEO Elon Musk speaks at the Paris Pantheon Sorbonne University as part of the COP21, United Nations Climate Change Conference in Paris on Dec. 2, 2015. An early prototype of Tesla Inc.’s proposed Optimus humanoid robot slowly and awkwardly walked onto a stage, turned, and waved ...

View more: Tesla robot walks, waves, but doesn't show off complex tasks

Firefly Aerospace reaches orbit with new Alpha rocket

A new aerospace company reached orbit with its second rocket launch and deployed multiple small satellites on Saturday. Firefly Aerospace’s Alpha rocket lifted off from Vandenberg Space Force Base, California, in early morning darkness and arced over the Pacific. “100% mission success,” Firefly tweeted later. A day earlier, an attempt ...

View more: Firefly Aerospace reaches orbit with new Alpha rocket

Powerful earthquake shakes Indonesia's Sumatra, kills 1

Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain A strong and shallow earthquake shook Indonesia’s Sumatra island on Saturday, killing a resident, injuring 11 and damaging more than a a dozen houses and buildings, police said. The magnitude 5.9 earthquake struck about 40 kilometers (24.8 miles) northeast of Sibolga, a coastal city in ...

View more: Powerful earthquake shakes Indonesia's Sumatra, kills 1

Behind C919: China's path to first self-developed large passenger aircraft

Two C919 aircraft park at the Beijing Capital International Airport, September 13, 2022. /CFP On a field outside the Shanghai Aircraft Manufacturing Center of Commercial Aircraft Corporation of China (COMAC) are two airplanes – a Y-10 jet and an MD-82 jet. They’ve been parked there for over 30 years, ...

View more: Behind C919: China's path to first self-developed large passenger aircraft

iPhone 14 Pro has the best selfie camera on a smartphone, according to DxOMark

(Image Courtesy: Apple) One of the major highlights of the iPhone 14 series is the new and improved front camera, which is equipped with autofocus feature. The addition of a new camera seems to have pay dividends as the iPhone 14 Pro has taken the crown for smartphone with the ...

View more: iPhone 14 Pro has the best selfie camera on a smartphone, according to DxOMark

NASA’s Ingenuity Helicopter Spots Foreign Object Debris on Mars

NASA’s Ingenuity Mars Helicopter acquired this image using its navigation camera. This camera is mounted in the helicopter’s fuselage and pointed directly downward to track the ground during flight. This image was acquired on November 6, 2021 (Sol 254 of the Perseverance rover mission) at the local mean solar ...

View more: NASA’s Ingenuity Helicopter Spots Foreign Object Debris on Mars

MediaTek, Invendis join hands for 5G, Wi-Fi router solutions

iStockChip maker MediaTek and Aglobal leader in IoT platforms and cloud computing solutions on Sunday announced a strategic collaboration to roll out 5G and Wi-Fi router solutions.The collaboration will enable a comprehensive portfolio of solutions and significant manufacturing capabilities in India.”We are thrilled to launch our 5G and Wi-Fi routers ...

View more: MediaTek, Invendis join hands for 5G, Wi-Fi router solutions

NASA Updates Crew Assignments for First Boeing Starliner Mission to Space Station

Boeing’s CST-100 Starliner crew ship approaches the International Space Station on May 20, 2022, on the company’s Orbital Flight Test-2 mission before automatically docking to the Harmony module’s forward port. The orbiting lab was flying 268 miles above the south Pacific at the time of this photograph. Credit: NASA ...

View more: NASA Updates Crew Assignments for First Boeing Starliner Mission to Space Station

Google Pixel 7, Pixel 7 Pro pre-orders in India kicks off on October 6

China's Shenzhou-13 taikonauts to conduct second spacewalk on Sunday

Exclusive interview: China's C919 features safety, comfort, efficiency

Samsung launches Galaxy Z Flip 4 in blue in India

Hong Kong start-up archiREEF wants to commercialise 3D-printed tiles, restore corals around the world

India launches 5G services at last

iPhone 6 added to list of vintage products by Apple

People still don't know what metaverse is all about: Tim Cook

Australian government slams Optus for cybersecurity breach

Foreign Object Debris on Mars Ingenuity Helicopter Leaves NASA JPL Team Baffled

Why It's Important for Your Business to Use Custom Boxes

Collisional Erosion Causes the Modification of Earth's Composition [STUDY]

OTHER TECH NEWS

;