mycc weighing options on piam appeal over workshop arrangement

PETALING JAYA: The Malaysia Competition Commission (MyCC) is weighing its options, which includes filing a judicial review, regarding the recent decision by the Competitions Appeal Tribunal to allow an appeal by the General Insurance Association of Malaysia (PIAM) and its 22 members against the commission’s decision two years ago.

MyCC had found that the association and the insurers had infringed the Competition Act 2010 in relation to the arrangement between PIAM and the Federation of Automobile Workshops Owners’ Association of Malaysia on the minimum hourly labour rates and spare part prices of six commonly used types of vehicles.

These vehicles are Proton, Perodua, Naza, Nissan, Toyota and Honda.

The three-member tribunal, in unanimously allowing the appeal on Sept 2, found that it was inaccurate to state the parts trade discounts and labour rates were determined by insurers.

However, in a statement yesterday, MyCC chief executive officer Iskandar Ismail said, “The decision by the tribunal may create ambiguity on how the law in relation to anti-competitive agreements made through associations is interpreted.”

MyCC pointed out that recent media articles on the case did not do justice to the decision of the tribunal, as they did not depict a complete picture of the decision.

The commission noted that in 2017 and again in 2020, both the central bank and PIAM had asserted that the infringing agreement were made based on a directive by the central bank.

“This was a defence that was put strongly by the insurers before the tribunal, which was supported by the central bank,” said MyCC, which also emphasised that the tribunal held that MyCC, by its nature and function as a quasi-judicial body, was empowered to interpret a provision of law whether it was relevant or otherwise.

“The mere fact that the outcome of the interpretation of the law affects another regulator’s power could not preclude MyCC from exercising its duties,” added MyCC.

The commission also pointed out that the tribunal ruled that the letters issued by the central bank, which were relied on heavily by PIAM and the insurers, could be construed as a directive.

“The tribunal ruled that the letters are merely letters urging the parties to resolve the commercial dispute, expedite negotiation and reach an agreement on the issues raised,” said MyCC.

Keyword: MyCC weighing options on PIAM appeal over workshop arrangement

TECH'S NEWS RELATED

2023 Maruti Jimny Spied Testing In Leh With Grand Vitara, Thar

Jimny gets a 1.5L K15 engine making 100 bhp and 130 Nm of torque mated to a 5-speed gearbox and a 4X4 transfer case 2023 Jimny Spied Testing In Leh Specs & Launch Jimny gets a 1.5L K15 engine making 100 bhp and 130 Nm of torque mated to ...

View more: 2023 Maruti Jimny Spied Testing In Leh With Grand Vitara, Thar

Electric car company car tax

There's never been a better time to choose an electric vehicle (EV) as a company car – here, we'll explain why...

View more: Electric car company car tax

2022 BMW M4 CSL review

The BMW M4 is only the third model in the car maker's history to wear the coveted CSL badge. Can it live up to the weight of expectation?...

View more: 2022 BMW M4 CSL review

New DS 4 vs Audi Q3 vs Cupra Formentor

With names like E-Tense, TFSIe and eHybrid, these SUVs are eager to promote their electrification and efficiency. But which one’s the boss?...

View more: New DS 4 vs Audi Q3 vs Cupra Formentor

Pandemic Hits Supply Chain, Costing a BMW Customer Dearly

Alex Magliozzi’s leased 2021 M340i needs a new steering rack, but it’s sitting in a Manhattan garage until a new one arrives—perhaps next summer.

View more: Pandemic Hits Supply Chain, Costing a BMW Customer Dearly

Demolition of historic Packard plant begins in Detroit

DETROIT — Demolition of the long-vacant Packard auto plant in Detroit started Thursday as crews began tearing apart an already crumbling exterior wall of the massive structure. A demolition claw ripped and tugged on decades-old bricks and concrete along the upper floors of the old eastside factory that for ...

View more: Demolition of historic Packard plant begins in Detroit

Are Tesla Owners Being Hoodwinked Into Thinking Full Self-Driving Autopilot Is Truly Autonomous?

Tesla faces a class action lawsuit because of Full Self-Driving Autopilot advertising What is the difference between Tesla Autopilot and full self-driving? What is Autopilot on a Tesla? How much does Autopilot cost for a Tesla vehicle? The video advertising this self-driving system used features not available to customers ...

View more: Are Tesla Owners Being Hoodwinked Into Thinking Full Self-Driving Autopilot Is Truly Autonomous?

Tesla Optimus deliveries should be possible within 3-5 years: Elon Musk

There were a lot of things to unpack regarding Tesla’s AI Day 2022, and a lot of it concerns the company’s humanoid robot, Optimus. A number of key details were shared about Optimus, including its specs and price. And during the event’s Q&A session, Elon Musk also hinted at ...

View more: Tesla Optimus deliveries should be possible within 3-5 years: Elon Musk

Top 5 Most Powerful Chevrolet Corvette Engines of the 1970s

Ferrari SP51 becomes latest one-off to wear the Prancing Horse badge

MG Motor Sep 2022 Sales Growth – Hector, Gloster, Astor

Tata Tiago EV | A Close Look & Preview

Ford Mustang California Special review – American muscle at its finest

Elon Musk touted the 'importance' of Tesla being a publicly traded company just 4 years after trying to take it private with his 'funding secured' tweet

Flooded Jeep Compass: My ordeal ends after getting full insurance claim

Best Spy Shots For The Week Of September 26

Porsche 963 Selects Lucky Numbers For U.S. Competition

New Tata Tiago EV: First Look

McLaren Artura supercar marks new chapter in tech and performance… and we promise it’s quite a green car

BMW M4 CSL review: does the £128k limited edition deserve the legendary badge?

OTHER TECH NEWS

;