offenders turning remorse into self-punishment to show contrition can sway people in their favor
Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain

In one of the first demonstrations of its kind, the Flinders University-led international study questioned hundreds of adults about acts of self-punishment which managed to garner their sympathy for the offender.

“Our research showed that even though people who self-punish may not aim to communicate their remorse with others, it can still help third-party observers understand their need for forgiveness or reconciliation with others,” says German researcher Dr. Stefanie Hechler, a visiting scholar at Flinders University, South Australia.

“Self-punishment—which ranges from physical harm to social withdrawal—can jeopardize relationships and be seen as a pathological and dysfunctional response to having done something wrong.

“Yet, at the same time, even small acts of self-punishment may have an interpersonal function to restore those relationships in jeopardy.”

In turn, this behavior might increase observers’ willingness to reconcile with the offender.

The research, published in the international Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, used the results of four studies conducted in the U.S. and Germany to test experimentally the effects of self-punishment on perceptions of remorse among third parties.

Flinders University Professor Michael Wenzel says the study demonstrates that self-punishment communicates messages of remorse, in a similar way as a verbal message from the offender does.

“Self-punishment is interpreted as the offender’s reaffirmation of the violated values as well as their own status degradation, so it addresses important concerns of others, such as ‘Does the offender endorse the same values as I do?’ or ‘Does the offender think they are better than others?'” adds Professor Wenzel, from the College of Education, Psychology and Social Work.

Prolonged social exclusion and self-harm also can be destructive when offenders do not get support in making amends to society in more positive ways, researchers warn.

“By extension, this study points to the problematic way society deals with wrongdoing, to the extent that it engages in exclusionary practices, or how the community refuses to even acknowledge the possibility of redemption,” adds Flinders University co-author Dr. Melissa de Vel-Palumbo, from the College of Business, Government and Law.

“One of the symbolic functions of self-punishment we have identified is the chance for offenders to signal that they endorse shared social norms,” she says.

“But if we don’t allow offenders to engage in pro-social roles and activities upon their return to society, including meaningful employment after a criminal conviction, then how can offenders demonstrate their commitment to pro-social norms?

“At the very least, we should support and create opportunities for people to demonstrate their commitment to a pro-social life.”

Dr. de Vel-Palumbo adds that restorative justice conferences is another way for offenders to communicate their remorse directly in a face-to-face interaction with their victims.

“It is not suitable for every offense, but it’s one way offenders can show their remorse, And by agreeing to make amends in a manner that is generally satisfying to victims and the community, these sorts of procedures might more constructively pave the way to forgiveness and reintegration.”

The article, “What does being hard on yourself communicate to others? The role of symbolic implications of self-punishment in attributions of remorse,” by Stefanie Hechler, Michael Wenzel, Lydia Woodyatt and Melissa de Vel-Palumbo, has been published in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology. More information: Stefanie Hechler et al, What does being hard on yourself communicate to others? The role of symbolic implications of self-punishment in attributions of remorse, Journal of Experimental Social Psychology (2022). DOI: 10.1016/j.jesp.2022.104305 Journal information: Journal of Experimental Social Psychology

Provided by Flinders University Citation: Offenders turning remorse into self-punishment to show contrition can sway people in their favor (2022, May 25) retrieved 25 May 2022 from https://phys.org/news/2022-05-remorse-self-punishment-contrition-sway-people.html This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Keyword: Offenders turning remorse into self-punishment to show contrition can sway people in their favor

TECH'S NEWS RELATED

New theory predicts Earth-like, watery planets exist around red dwarfs

Figure. 1: Artist’s impression of the molten surface of a young rocky planet reacting with its primordial atmosphere to form water vapor. Credit: Tadahiro Kimura Recent exoplanet exploration has focused on the discovery of temperate rocky planets like the Earth, which are often called habitable planets. Most of the ...

View more: New theory predicts Earth-like, watery planets exist around red dwarfs

Suspected Chinese hackers tampered with widely used customer chat program

ETtech The scope and scale of the hack was not immediately clear. In a message, Comm100 said it had fixed its software earlier Thursday and that more details would soon be forthcoming. The company did not immediately respond to follow-up requests for information. Suspected Chinese hackers tampered with widely used ...

View more: Suspected Chinese hackers tampered with widely used customer chat program

Discovery of new microscopic species expands the tree of life

Legendrea loyezae with trailing tentacles. Credit: Bournemouth University Scientists have discovered several very rare species of microorganisms, some of which have never been seen before and others which have escaped the curious eyes of scientists for over a hundred years. The discovery of these elusive species, published in the ...

View more: Discovery of new microscopic species expands the tree of life

Tencent shifts focus to majority deals, overseas gaming assets for growth-sources

ETtech The shift comes as the world’s number one gaming firm by revenue is counting on global markets for its future growth, which requires a strong portfolio of chart-topping games, the sources aid. Tencent is resetting its M&A strategy to put more focus on buying majority stakes mainly in overseas ...

View more: Tencent shifts focus to majority deals, overseas gaming assets for growth-sources

5G launch | Jio will deliver 5G services in every town by December 2023, says Mukesh Ambani. Read full text

The rollout of 5G in India is not an ordinary event in India’s telecom history, says RIL Chairman Mukesh Ambani Reliance Industries Chairman Mukesh Ambani on October 1 said that telecom company Jio will launch 5G services across India by December 2023. Ambani was speaking at the India Mobile ...

View more: 5G launch | Jio will deliver 5G services in every town by December 2023, says Mukesh Ambani. Read full text

Can investment zones level up the UK’s tech hubs?

Investment zones: the devil is in the detail The wrong tool for the right job? ‘Destruction zones’ Among the many policy directions announced in Chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng’s calamitous mini-budget was the announcement of low-tax, low-regulation investment zones. The idea is to incentivise investment in specific regions across the UK. ...

View more: Can investment zones level up the UK’s tech hubs?

Microsoft Brings Back Task Manager to Windows Taskbar in Latest Build

More Features in New Preview Buid What’s New in Task Manager Microsoft has finally brought back the Task Manager to where it rightfully belongs on the Windows taskbar. Windows users who subscribe to the Dev Channel of Windows Insider will have access to a patch updating their Windows 11 ...

View more: Microsoft Brings Back Task Manager to Windows Taskbar in Latest Build

Chinese EV start-up Li Auto launches L8 SUV aimed squarely at German rivals BMW, Audi and Mercedes-Benz

Chinese smart electric-vehicle (EV) maker Li Auto launched its third model, the L8, to mount a challenge to global marques like BMW and Audi amid an accelerated pace of EV adoption on the mainland. The Beijing-based carmaker on Friday began taking orders for the six-seater SUV, which is priced ...

View more: Chinese EV start-up Li Auto launches L8 SUV aimed squarely at German rivals BMW, Audi and Mercedes-Benz

Sony XE300 Bluetooth Speaker Review: Good, but Could Be Better

Hack puts Latin American security agencies on edge

No Terminator: Musk teases 'useful' humanoid robot

What reptile's bones can teach us about Earth's perilous past

Strong Geomagnetic Storm Could Produce Atypical Northern Lights as Far South as in the US

Winds of change drive 'alarming' rate of ocean warming

India 'must toughen goals' to achieve zero emissions, says study

Stretchy, bio-inspired synaptic transistor can enhance or weaken device memories

Exploring the plasma loading mechanism of radio jets launched from black holes

Exploring Australians' climate change views, practices, and capabilities

Researchers explore driving factors affecting sustainability of endorheic regions

Human 'blastoids' offer medical hope but also deep ethical challenges

OTHER TECH NEWS

;